Ron Pope Motorsports                California Custom Roadsters               

Keep the mechanical fuel pump or go Elect???

2xcrash

Member
Should I keep my mechanical fuel pump or run a electric one. I figure Im still ruffing everything in now so now would be the time to do it.
I'm only running a 2 bl right now to a 1950 caddy motor, but will go to a duel duce intake down the road. It's not going to ever be a blown nitro beast so do I even need the extra electrical thingamajig to fail on me?
 
Should I keep my mechanical fuel pump or run a electric one. I figure Im still ruffing everything in now so now would be the time to do it.
I'm only running a 2 bl right now to a 1950 caddy motor, but will go to a duel duce intake down the road. It's not going to ever be a blown nitro beast so do I even need the extra electrical thingamajig to fail on me?

If you were running a small block Chevy I'd say go with the mechanical pump as you can get one most anywhere if it broke down on you. However, with that Caddy you might find it harder to find a replacement pump in a breakdown situation. So I'd go with the electric in this case. IMHO
 
I'm with ex junk on this one. if the pump you have is a bit suspect, now might be the time to change it out. Buy a good quality pump , (Holley, Edelbrock, Carter, etc) and a big, good quality filter between the tank and pump. How many late model cars have electric pumps and do a couple of hundred thousand miles without issues? all of them! . Just don't run it out of gas!
 
I have a Carter electric pump on my T. I'm running a Vortec block that isn't machined for a mech pump pushrod.

The Carter is designed to be cooled and lubricated by the fuel like a modern EFI pump. It's noisy though. I can hear it running over the sound of the engine.

I also added an impact sensing switch from a Ford. It shuts the pump down in the event of a hard hit.

Another advantage of an electric pump is that you can prime the carb if the car has been sitting long enough for the fuel in the bowl to evaporate.
 
Personally, I don't like electric pumps for hot rods because they are noisy and potentially dangerous unless you have an inertia switch as Hotrod46 mentioned. I would keep the mechanical pump and buy an extra if you are worried about finding one. But in reality, with as much as these cars are driven, most any pump on any motor will outlast most of us....

Due to the lack of space inherent with these cars, it mostly prevents us from carrying spare parts for the most part. Even a flat tire can put you on a flat bed headed home. It's important to have good towing insurance, IMO.
 
Mechanical pumps are ugly. Put a pretty cover plate on the hole, mount a good electric pump under the car and put a filter in front of it. Now EFI pumps can be noisy as hell, but pumps for carbs are very quiet. And in our buckets, engine noise and singing pipes drown out most all sounds, including the screams of oblivious pedestrians.
 
Mechanical pumps are ugly. Put a pretty cover plate on the hole, mount a good electric pump under the car and put a filter in front of it. Now EFI pumps can be noisy as hell, but pumps for carbs are very quiet. And in our buckets, engine noise and singing pipes drown out most all sounds, including the screams of oblivious pedestrians.

As the old saying goes, "beauty is in the eye of the beholder". I see nothing wrong with a neatly installed mechanical pump.IMHO



Jim
 
I recommend gravity feed.
 
I recommend gravity feed.

I know that was intended as a joke, but it does remind me of something that happened to me. I had a rail dune buggy with a tank mounted above the engine. After running it one day I parked it in front of my shop. A few hours later I noticed a puddle under it. I had forgotten to turn the fuel valve off and the needle had stuck open. Gas had filled the engine, seeped past the rings and was dripping out of the headers. The fuel pump didn't stop it either. I had to drain and change the oil a couple of times just to make sure it was cleaned up.

Needless to say, I didn't forget the fuel valve again!
 
"beauty is in the eye of the beholder" I always thought that was "beauty is in the eyes of the beerholder". LOL
I'll drink to that! And I'm maybe set in my ways; all my cars have had electric pumps, and I got used to doing it that way. How about a billet mechanical pump, with fins and a choice of anodized finishes?
 
So this is a 1950 331 caddy motor. If I'm out on the road and it goes out there's not going to be one at auto zone. But it's cool looking and I'm for sure not going with a billet fined anodized pump. image.jpgimage.jpg image.jpg
I wonder if there's a way to gut the pump but keep it on the motor then run the pump from under the chassis?
 
You know, I think you could put an electric pump upstream from the mechanical one, and they would work together. Then if the mechanical one failed, the electric one would keep the fuel going.
 
So this is a 1950 331 caddy motor. If I'm out on the road and it goes out there's not going to be one at auto zone. But it's cool looking and I'm for sure not going with a billet fined anodized pump. View attachment 10460View attachment 10460 View attachment 10462
I wonder if there's a way to gut the pump but keep it on the motor then run the pump from under the chassis?
Well, to each their own. The mechanicals will last a long time. BUT, heres one thing to consider.....trash and water. Mechanicals back in the old days would pump most anything....Honey, old motor oil, you name it....even rust outta the old jalopys fueltank and right in thr middle of that carbs float bowl.
Newer diaphrams in mech. pumps are lighter, materials thickness wise, so they are less durable. Because if you put that newer rebuilt pump from one on the performance caddy places, its gonna be like new, but its gonna feel outta place with the new fuels of today. And if you break down out there somewhere....AutoZone, Pepboys, and O'Reillys ain't gonna have a replacement in stock. If it were a Chevy or Ford, I'd say run it.

Yes, you can gut the pump, which is what I would do, and use just the inlet/outlet w/ the glass bowl. Mount a good electric back in the back, a good filter ahead of the pump, food thru the gutted mech. one into you carb(s). Once you take the pump apart, you'll see the moving parts that will need to be removed and blocked off, once thats done, seal her up and reinstall.
If your scared of messing things up, talk to one of the old caddy perf. specialists that you'll be frequenting during your build, they'll fix you up....

Yes, a good electric will push gas thru a mech. pump....but if you loose that diaphram....you COULD fill the crankcase full of fuel....
Its your car, we can give you the info to make a informed decision, but your gonna haveta be the one to decide....
Those Valve Covers would look good with the Caddy name blacked out....
 
Last edited:
Hijack--How much pressure does the chrome mechanical pump for a 302" Ford put out? I think mine from Jegs is more than the Edelbrock600 can handle.
 
Hijack--How much pressure does the chrome mechanical pump for a 302" Ford put out? I think mine from Jegs is more than the Edelbrock600 can handle.
Shouldn't be more than about 4-5psi....I've seen them hit as much as 7....all depends. Thats the reason why you need to gauge it....Regulate it to about 3 psi and you should be good....Some people will do 5....whatever....
 
Its your car, we can give you the info to make a informed decision, but your gonna haveta be the one to decide....
And this is why I come here!!!

Those Valve Covers would look good with the Caddy name blacked out....
Yep just the way I'm going till I can afford some offy valve covers and duel carb intake! I'll get her running first then the speed goddies!
 

     Ron Pope Motorsports                Advertise with Us!     
Back
Top