Garage Merch                Ron Pope Motorsports                California Custom Roadsters               

My T-bucket frame

Spanky

Moderator
Staff member
I have a Spirit Cars frame which is 2" x 3" 3/16"-wall. I know Speedway uses 1/8" wall for their frames and I don't hear any complaints of frame-flex. What are the rest of you using for frames and do you think 3/16" wall tubing is overkill?
 

Attachments

  • 3 spring behind.jpg
    3 spring behind.jpg
    30.9 KB · Views: 67
I think 1/8” is fine. There have been a bunch of frames with it used. I seem to remember going to 3/16” tube was a marketing idea so the frame could be tapped for brake line and wire clamps to clean up the looks of installation.
 
Spanky that is how my frame is done on the Yelot, It was built back in the 80's in Austin Texas as best as I can tell.....I have since renforced it with an .5inch bar runing underneath, mostly my thoughts for overkill.......
 
With 2 rails you get a much stronger frame in vertical plane. That example could use more vertices but still adequate.
 
mine is 2x4 1/8 (narrows to 2x3 at front) and many miles in 30+ years. I think anything more is just wasted.
 
mine is 2x4 1/8 (narrows to 2x3 at front) and many miles in 30+ years. I think anything more is just wasted.
Well I have to say you are obviously Wrong, LOL! I don't like having to drill big 1/2" holes to install to install threadserts. of some kind.

OK, go ahead and slap me around, I can take it Mr. perfect!!!

I have always drilled/tapped my frame with 5/16 or 3/8" threads, but I'm always been very careful about how tight I tightened devices, fuels pump, filters) with a 1/8" wall thickness .... think about it how many threads are there in 1/8".

So to stir the pot, do you use fine thread or course???
.
 
Well, it's been 30+ years since we built my car, so I gottta think a bit. The only high stress connections I recall are the 4 bar mounts. We used crush tubes and long bolts for those to go all the way thru the frame rails. I know there are some low stress mounts, like headlights ( used 4 bolts each for those). I imagine we used fine threads there. I'd look, but can't work on the car now that I'm a wimp.
 
Definitely not 1/8” for me. Just too thin, plus as others mentioned it can be tapped.
 
Just answering a question, not wanting to get involved in discussion. 5/16" UNC = 18 TPI or 2.25 threads in 1/8". 3/8" UNC = 16 TPI or 2 threads in 1/8". Both 5/16" and 3/8" UNF are 24 TPI = 3 threads in 1/8"
 
I've been using 2x3 3/16 tube for the usual reason of being able to tap for line clamps and brackets and it makes a stronger base for welding suspension brackets in place; whether those reasons are overkill is a matter of personal choice. I also use 3/16 when boxing original frames; same reasoning.
 
More opinions . . .

 
This was copied from the Rat Rods Rule forum:
"With rec tube, 1/8" 4x2 deflects about 1/3 less than 3/16" 3x2. It's the height of the sidewall that makes the biggest difference."
I don't know how true that is, but I thought it was interesting.
 
While I understand debating the different tubing sizes for a consensus of opinion, I'd imagine that having 3D modelling would provide solid (get it?) data points for strength. I also imagine that additional crossmembers would change things a bunch.
Spanky's round tube example shows that the basic design isn't triangulated or stiffened well. Obviously, a solid crossmember that spans the area taken up by the drivetrain would help, but kind of ignores the whole point!
If you look at an Ariel Atom chassis, it's obvious the standard T chassis is lacking, but the whole point of a T is to be traditional and simple.
Look at Marty Strode's Track T-bucket frames. It has the typical perimeter rectangular tubing, but much more too.
So the whole exercise seems to be debating what type of wicker is used to weave a chair seat. It isn't the best solution and depends on how big the person (intended use) who will be sitting in it is. A child at home or a tiki bar with general public rough use.
img20170201_15133302.jpg
 
BTW, all that is coming from a place where my old frame is original frame rails, partially boxed and mixed with rect tubing.
Certainly NOT the optimum! There will be changes to things and a lot of cleanup in the future, but the main stuff will remain.
20240918_091342small.jpg
 
"....... 1/8" 4x2 deflects about 1/3 less than 3/16" 3x2. It's the height of the sidewall that makes the biggest difference."
I don't know how true that is, but I thought it was interesting."
the pic below is the rear frame from a C-5 Corvette, sawed off just ahead of the crash beam, for installation into a Corvair. I was amazed that Corvettes use such thin metal .
 

Attachments

  • monzora c5 cross-section.jpeg
    monzora c5 cross-section.jpeg
    187 KB · Views: 4

     Ron Pope Motorsports                Advertise with Us!     
Back
Top