Vacuum advance, where we are concerned with these cars is mostly for driveability. The engine will not make any more power with or without the vacuum advance connected. At full throttle you have no vacuum so the vacuum advance does nothing. From a performance standpoint vacuum advance is useless.
Now for the driveability issue. A well set up distributor with a full mechanical advance will work perfectly and will have excellent driveability. The first thing is to set up you mechanical advance. You normally want a lot of initial advance with about 34-38 degrees total advance as soon as the engine will take it without detonation. I normally set up my distributors at 16 degrees initial advance with an additional 20 degrees (for a total of 36 degree) all in by 2500 RPM if the engine will take it that soon. High compression engines may detonate with that fast of an advance so you may need to have the advance come in later for a high compression engines.
You can add the vacuum advance and it will definitely make a nicer idle and will have better part throttle response as you will be putting in additional timing. Fuel economy will also be better. But I have found that on high compression engines you will need an adjustable vacuum advance canister to avoid detonation.
You basically want to set up your mechanical advance for full power. Then hook up you vacuum advance and see if the engine will take it without detonation. If it detonates get an adjustable canister and start taking timing off it until you get rid of the detonation. This will give you the best performance, drivability and fuel economy, but can take quite a while to achieve.
I have no time to deal with it anymore so I just set my mechanical advance and forget about the vacuum advance. Car will make the same power with or without the vacuum advance so screw it
BTW the lower compression motors will take better to vacuum advance than higher compression engines.
Now for the driveability issue. A well set up distributor with a full mechanical advance will work perfectly and will have excellent driveability. The first thing is to set up you mechanical advance. You normally want a lot of initial advance with about 34-38 degrees total advance as soon as the engine will take it without detonation. I normally set up my distributors at 16 degrees initial advance with an additional 20 degrees (for a total of 36 degree) all in by 2500 RPM if the engine will take it that soon. High compression engines may detonate with that fast of an advance so you may need to have the advance come in later for a high compression engines.
You can add the vacuum advance and it will definitely make a nicer idle and will have better part throttle response as you will be putting in additional timing. Fuel economy will also be better. But I have found that on high compression engines you will need an adjustable vacuum advance canister to avoid detonation.
You basically want to set up your mechanical advance for full power. Then hook up you vacuum advance and see if the engine will take it without detonation. If it detonates get an adjustable canister and start taking timing off it until you get rid of the detonation. This will give you the best performance, drivability and fuel economy, but can take quite a while to achieve.
I have no time to deal with it anymore so I just set my mechanical advance and forget about the vacuum advance. Car will make the same power with or without the vacuum advance so screw it
BTW the lower compression motors will take better to vacuum advance than higher compression engines.